The Gratitude Gap: Leading with Appreciation in Schools During November Fatigue

gratitude leadership schools

This is Week 1 of our November series: “November Notes: Reflect. Recalibrate. Restore.” Throughout this month, we’ll explore how school leaders can use this season of pause between intensity and renewal to build more sustainable, human-centered practices.

November arrives in schools like an uninvited guest. The initial energy of fall has faded, winter break feels impossibly distant, and everyone is running on fumes. I’ve spent enough time in schools to know that this is when leaders feel the weight most acutely. You’re managing behavior incidents, coordinating Thanksgiving logistics, preparing for parent conferences, and trying to keep your team from completely unraveling before December.

In these moments, when the to-do list feels endless and morale is flagging, gratitude can feel like one more thing we should be doing but can’t possibly fit in. But here’s what I’ve learned from reading recent research on teacher burnout and leadership practices: gratitude isn’t a luxury. It’s a strategic leadership tool, particularly in seasons of collective fatigue.

Understanding the Current Crisis

Let’s start with what we’re actually dealing with. According to recent data from RAND Corporation, 60% of K-12 educators report feeling burned out, with 44% saying the stress and disappointments of teaching aren’t worth it. That’s not just a number. That’s more than half of your faculty questioning whether they can sustain this work.

The November slump isn’t new, but the baseline exhaustion people are carrying into this season is different than it was even five years ago. Teachers are managing challenging student behaviors (cited by 45% as their primary stressor), dealing with inadequate compensation, and taking on extra duties because of staffing shortages. When you add the typical November fatigue to this foundation of burnout, you get a recipe for real crisis.

As school leaders, we can’t solve systemic issues like teacher pay or fix behavioral challenges overnight. But we can create micro-moments of recognition that help people feel seen during the hardest stretches. That’s where gratitude becomes strategic.

Why Gratitude Matters More Than You Think

I used to think gratitude was soft. Nice, but not essential. Then I started reading the research and seeing the data. Studies on teacher burnout have found that social support and gratitude are negatively correlated with burnout, while loneliness is positively correlated. In other words, when teachers feel appreciated and connected, they’re significantly less likely to burn out.

Research from Edutopia confirms that gratitude is “the easiest, fastest, and most inexpensive way to improve performance and enhance enthusiasm about work.” When school leaders are intentional about showing authentic appreciation, teacher retention, productivity, and morale all increase; that’s not a feel-good platitude. That’s an operational strategy.

What’s happening neurologically when we express or receive gratitude is worth understanding. Gratitude activates the brain’s reward system, releasing dopamine and serotonin. Over time, this rewiring makes people more resilient to stress and more likely to approach challenges with a positive outlook. In a profession where emotional exhaustion is rampant, building these neural pathways matters.

The Gap Between Knowing and Doing

Here’s the problem: we all know gratitude is important. But according to NASUWT data, only 29% of teachers reported that their schools provided adequate measures to manage stress and burnout in 2024. There’s a massive gap between understanding that people need support and actually creating structures that deliver it.

Why does this gap exist? In my conversations with school leaders, I hear three main obstacles:

Time scarcity. You’re managing three crises before 9 am. Finding time to write thank-you notes feels impossible.

Concern about authenticity. You worry that gratitude practices will feel performative or hollow, particularly with faculty who are legitimately struggling.

Uncertainty about implementation. You want to show appreciation, but you’re not sure how to do it in a way that actually lands.

These are real concerns. But they’re also solvable. The key is building gratitude practices that are specific, sustainable, and integrated into existing workflows rather than added as one more thing.

Making Gratitude Practical: Strategies That Actually Work

Let me share what I’ve seen work in schools, informed by both research and practical experience.

Build Recognition Into Existing Structures

One principal described in recent research created what he calls a “positive note system” using a simple Google Doc. Staff can log positive observations throughout the day, which automatically generates emails to relevant people. His school of 300 students sent 1,600 positive notes in a single year. The system is embedded in their workflow, not added on top of it.

You don’t need fancy software. You could adapt this by:

  • Setting a daily reminder to send one specific note of appreciation before leaving campus
  • Using your regular classroom walk-throughs to capture what you see people doing well, then following up with a quick email
  • Dedicating the first five minutes of leadership team meetings to sharing one thing you noticed someone else doing effectively.

The key is specificity. “Great job” doesn’t carry much weight. “I noticed how you redirected that student in the hallway with such patience, and I watched him completely reset after talking with you.” shows you’re paying attention to the invisible work teachers do all day.

Create Space for Peer-to-Peer Recognition

Research from the American Association of School Personnel Administrators emphasizes that peer recognition builds community in ways that top-down appreciation alone cannot. Teachers spend most of their time with colleagues, and they often have the clearest view of each other’s challenges and victories.

gratitude leadership schools

Consider implementing:

  • A gratitude board in the faculty lounge where staff can post notes to colleagues
  • Time at the beginning of faculty meetings for staff to share specific observations about each other’s work
  • A simple notecard system where people can drop anonymous or signed notes of appreciation in colleagues’ mailboxes

The Greater Good Science Center research on gratitude in schools found that creating “identity safe” spaces where people feel comfortable expressing appreciation is crucial. This means establishing norms where vulnerability is safe and differences are celebrated as assets.

Schedule Gratitude Conferences

This practice, recommended by school leadership experts, involves blocking time on your calendar for short meetings with individual staff members specifically to provide personalized, authentic praise. Not to discuss problems. Not to review performance. Just to express specific gratitude.

These don’t need to be long. Fifteen minutes where you share three specific things you’ve noticed this person doing well can be transformative. The key is making these routine rather than random. Put them on your calendar like you would any other important meeting.

One suggestion: start with your most burnt-out staff members. The teachers who are struggling most are often the ones who receive the least positive feedback because they’re in crisis mode. Breaking that cycle matters.

Make It Public When Appropriate

The same principal mentioned earlier also publicly expresses gratitude to teachers in front of students at key points in the year, then invites students to do the same. “All of a sudden, as it gets going, the students are in front of their teacher and their peers telling their teacher why they are grateful for them,” he shared.

Public acknowledgment multiplies the impact. It signals to the entire community what you value. It gives others permission to express appreciation. It creates shared moments of connection when people are feeling isolated.

Consider:

  • Highlighting specific teachers’ work in newsletters or all-school meetings
  • Creating opportunities for students to express appreciation during advisory or morning meetings
  • Sharing specific examples of excellent teaching during parent meetings

Focus on Presence and Listening

Research on educational leadership emphasizes that one of the most basic ways to improve morale is simply being visible and listening to employees’ aspirations, concerns, and struggles. This applies to all campus leaders, not just first-line supervisors.

In the exhaustion of November, your presence matters more than you realize. Walking the halls, eating lunch in the faculty room, dropping by classrooms not to evaluate but simply to see what people are doing—these acts communicate care. They create opportunities to notice the work that would otherwise remain invisible.

This isn’t about adding hours to your day. It’s about being intentional with the time you’re already spending in your building.

The Cultural Shift: From Transactional to Relational

Here’s what I want you to understand: gratitude practices are not about checking boxes or implementing a new program. They’re about shifting from transactional relationships (“I need you to do X”) to relational ones (“I see you, I value what you bring, and I’m grateful we’re doing this work together”).

gratitude leadership schools

Research on gratitude and teacher wellbeing found that gratitude is crucial in fostering positive interpersonal relationships and strengthening bonds between teachers and students. The same principle applies to relationships between leaders and faculty.

When you cultivate a culture of genuine appreciation, several things happen:

People feel less alone. Burnout thrives in isolation. Recognition creates connection.

The invisible work becomes visible. So much of what teachers do goes unnoticed. Naming it changes how people experience their own contribution.

Resilience increases. Studies show that gratitude helps people focus on positive aspects even during adversity, building the very resilience needed to survive November and beyond.

Turnover decreases. The principal who implemented systematic gratitude practices saw the lowest teacher turnover in years at his school. While he couldn’t definitively prove causation, the correlation is significant.

What Doesn’t Work

Not all gratitude practices are equally effective. Research from EdWeek identified several pitfalls:

Generic praise. “You’re doing great” feels hollow. Specific observations about particular actions or decisions carry weight.

One-and-done initiatives. A single gratitude activity during a staff meeting won’t create cultural change. You need sustained practice.

Public pressure without trust. Forcing people to share gratitude publicly before you’ve built a foundation of psychological safety can backfire, leaving them feeling exposed rather than appreciated.

Gratitude as compensation. Expressing appreciation doesn’t substitute for fair pay, reasonable workloads, or adequate support. It complements those things but cannot replace them.

The research is clear: gratitude practices work best when they’re authentic, specific, sustained, and embedded in a broader culture of support.

Starting Small: Your November Action Plan

If you’re reading this thinking, “I can barely keep my head above water, how am I supposed to add gratitude practices?” I hear you. Start small. Pick one thing from this list and commit to it for the next three weeks:

  1. The Daily Note: Before you leave campus each day, send one specific email of appreciation to a staff member.
  2. The Walk-Through Follow-Up: When you do classroom observations, note one specific thing each teacher did well and email it to them within 24 hours.
  3. The Friday Shout-Out: In your Friday all-staff email, include a specific recognition of one person’s work that week.
  4. The Peer Gratitude Moment: Start every faculty meeting with 2-3 minutes for staff to acknowledge each other’s contributions.
  5. The Student Voice: Create one opportunity per week for students to express their appreciation for teachers (e.g., passing out notecards during advisory).

The goal isn’t perfection. It’s movement toward a culture where people feel genuinely seen and valued.

Looking Beyond November

Here’s the truth: November will be hard. December will bring its own challenges. But if we use this season of fatigue as a catalyst for building more sustainable appreciation practices, we can shift how people experience the year as a whole.

Research from Moreland University reminds us that recognition isn’t just about individual moments. It’s about creating systems and cultures where appreciation becomes the norm rather than the exception, where people are thanked not occasionally but routinely, where the invisible work of teaching and supporting students is consistently made visible.

This is particularly crucial given what we know about the current state of our profession. With 78% of teachers having considered leaving since the pandemic, and burnout rates significantly higher than in other professions, we cannot afford to treat gratitude as optional. It’s a retention strategy. It’s a wellness intervention. It’s how we help people survive and, eventually, thrive.

As you move through these next few weeks, I encourage you to notice who’s holding the invisible load. Who’s going above and beyond? Who’s mediating conflicts during lunch? Who’s covering classes for absent colleagues without complaint? Who’s bringing calm to chaos?

These people need to know you see them. Not because it will fix everything. But because in seasons of collective fatigue, being seen is sometimes the difference between staying and leaving.

The Invitation

Gratitude isn’t a magic solution. It won’t eliminate burnout or solve systemic problems. But it is a powerful tool that’s available to you right now, in this moment, without additional budget or approval.

The question is whether we’ll use it intentionally rather than waiting for a Thanksgiving assembly to make us pause and reflect.

November is hard. But November can also be the season when we recalibrate how we lead, moving from transactional management to relational care, when we close the gratitude gap by building appreciation into the rhythm of daily school life rather than treating it as an occasional add-on.

Your teachers are exhausted. You’re exhausted. Everyone is running on fumes. But in that exhaustion, small acts of genuine recognition can create moments of connection that sustain us through the hardest stretches.

That’s not fluff. That’s strategy. And it might be exactly what your community needs right now.

Bridget Johnson's Signature

Bridget Johnson, Founder, Deans' Roundtable

Bridget Johnson, a former associate executive director, has worked in education for much of her career, primarily in independent schools and nonprofits. As a former dean of students and director of special programs, she has helped schools expand their offerings while maintaining their core values. Bridget now works as the founder of the Deans’ Roundtable and an independent consultant helping educational institutions implement data-driven strategies that support their unique missions.

Skip to content